December 04, 2002
Dogs and Demons: General Impressions

After reading Joi Ito's mention of this book, I decided to pick it up and read it. I must say, I read this book faster than I've read any book in recent memory. It doesn't even look like anyone's read it yet. I could probably even return it still ;) Anyway, I liked it. There are many points lacking throughout, but all in all, I think it's high time this book was written, and people begin to try to understand that Japan has serious chronic and systemic problems. Many of these are almost impossible to see even within Japan; many of them are invisible precisely because they are always in plain sight.

There is so much to talk about with regard to this book, it's truly overwhelming. Just quoting the facts and figures that shocked me would take pages and pages. I know a lot about Japan, but I honestly can't imagine how Mr. Kerr managed to find out about some of the more sensitive issues without resorting to 'watergate' methods... ;)

If you can overlook the author's sometimes repetitive aesthetic judgements and prejudices, in the end you will see a picture difficult to swallow. Difficult, mostly because it is a sad state of affairs, and it is hard to see any easy way out. Well, there is no easy way out for Japan — the nation will at some point have to face these issues and change the way it does business.

I'll be writing more about the interesting things I found in this book, but for now, I'll just say this. The author at one point raises the specter of the failure of the Japanese movie industry. The industry is currently bleeding cash, and there is no real hope of a renaissance soon. Mr. Kerr talks about how one of the big three Japanese movie companies depended for so long on the proceeds from endless sequels of "Otoko wa tsurai yo." Japan is in a state of stagnation partially because of this mentality — the obsession with riding cookie-cutter scripts for success to their grave, then beating them to get up for years before realizing they're actually dead.

All is not lost for Japan. Anyone that would say so would have to be fantastically short-sighted. But the first step to fixing problems is always opening them up to the light of public scrutiny.

Posted by Trevor Hill at December 04, 2002 05:05 PM

Glad you read this book. You're right. There are some problems, but it is a "must read" book.

I just spent the evening with Governor Domoto of Chiba talking about the logging/forest planning issue. It's a real problem.

Anyone want to come to Chiba and chop down a few trees?

Posted by: Joi Ito at February 8, 2003 07:15 AM

I'd really like to see them try to remove some of the eyesores and make money by turning rural areas into hot-spring destinations, etc...

The only way to save the environment, IMHO, is by providing an economic incentive to do so... :)

If you could get even one such project going, I think it might start to spread. No one dislikes making money... :)

Posted by: Trevor Hill at February 8, 2003 03:02 PM