February 22, 2003
Human Shields or Pawns?

There's a very interesting article at Salon about the self-described "human shields" going to Iraq to try to prevent or deter war.

I respect anyone who has the guts to do something like this. But I see a recurring theme here, one I've thought about many times in the past, and which the article makes clear: People with ideologies tend to lose their common sense sometimes -- lose sight of the realities of power in the world.

The article talks about how in 1990 Iraq kidnapped westerners and brought them to military targets in order to deter strikes to those locations. They talk in particular about one man's horrible experiences, and his opinion on the current voluntary human shields.

I think the tactic could be effective. But putting your life in the hands of Hussein and hoping for your wishes to be respected is losing sight of reality. Some people in the world have respect for principles, etc. Some only respect the laws of nature. I believe Hussein is one of the latter, and I'm truly saddened by the thought of what these individuals will most probably experience...

Posted by Trevor Hill at February 22, 2003 10:46 PM

Sorry, Trevor: but as in all things, the reality is more complicated than the news leads you to believe.

Only some of the "human shields" left, because of what they felt were Hussein's attempts to use them. The rest stayed on, and their numbers are growing. It's true that they were offered a list of places to stand vigil, but they had a choice as to where they could go, or not.

Posted by: Neil Mick at March 8, 2003 05:00 AM

Thanks for the additional information. The picture painted by the media is always piecemeal, which is exactly why we always have to remain skeptical...

I still am more inclined to believe that these volunteers are being manipulated in a way they may be too naive to realize, just like most pro-war Americans are...

Posted by: Trevor Hill at March 11, 2003 03:07 PM